Friday, September 13, 2013

My Brush with Euthanasia: Forget Not Love

This post conforms to the blog rules.Euthanasia is a terrible thing. I had a brush with it about a month ago while on a geriatric ward. This might surprise and scare you. Just to clarify, this actually happened. I am exaggerating nothing.

I was reviewing an older patient's chart at the nursing station before rounds. This person was on dozens of medications. The home medication list was three pages long. Everything was carefully listed by doses, times, and routes (oral, otic, ophthalmic, topical, nasal...), but the sheer volume was overwhelming. On top of the drugs for medical and mental problems, there were various  prescriptions and OTC remedies to cover side effects of the first drugs.

(If polypharmacy is new to you, then let me explain how these lists grow. A man of 64 on no medicines has some chest pain and goes to his doctor. He leaves with instructions to take a baby aspirin every day. And, because his blood pressure was high, he also leaves with a prescription for a water pill and a blood pressure medicine.

(Fast forward four years. Despite his daily three drugs, the man ends up in the hospital with a heart attack. He leaves with a stent, an antiplatelet agent, a pill for cholesterol, and an ACE inhibitor.

(Fast forward another eight years. Our man seems to be getting lost around the house and can't balance the checkbook very well any more. He's put on two drugs for dementia. Thyroid replacement is added because a thyroid test was high. His wife added a multivitamin, CoQ10, and glucosamine to keep him healthy after that fall he had last Christmas, and he also has nitroglycerin on hand, for that chest pain that started all this. He's now up to a dozen drugs, not counting any OTC painkillers, eye drops, or occasional antibiotics.)

Back to my story: I looked at the three page list of medicines in my hand, aghast. How burdensome this regimen had become for the patient and caretakers! What was this person's quality of life like, with so much intervention? This all seemed like artifice to replace the functions of a failing body. It seemed like torture to prolong a life. And for what?

I looked up from the page out to the patients beyond the nursing station counter. Half of the patients on this ward seemed over-medicated to me. They sat in their wheelchairs unaware of their surroundings. Other professionals I had learned from, including very compassionate hospice nurses, liberally took patients off medicines toward the end of life. I liked this palliative, simplifying approach. Too much medicine is a cloying thing, a clinging to numbers or days. I thought to myself, "why not just take this patient off everything and let her go peacefully?" No more surprise bruises from aspirin, no more dizziness from the blood pressure pills. No more bother with all these pills and suppositories and drops.

But today I looked at her three page list, I saw one problem with the remove-the-medicines approach. Two of this patient's medications were high-potency antipsychotics in high doses. And the rest of the regimen was like a teetering game of Jenga: remove one thing, no matter how extraneous, and the rest collapses. I groaned inwardly. We could not let this person off her medicines...it would not be peaceful or safe, and it would not improve her quality of life. If medication withdrawal couldn't be done, what could? How could this patient and her caregivers be relieved of all this?

"What if," I thought, "What if we just gave a little too much of something?"

Immediately I was alarmed. Where did that thought come from? Did I just suggest to myself that I should euthanize a person? I had. I was thinking about giving something (e.g. a benzodiazepine) to let her just slip away. I was horrified at the thought I had just produced.

How did I get to that point? I was thinking about burdens and quality of life! How did I go so far astray?

Looking back, I realized that in the few days I'd worked on that ward, I had taken on the attitude of the attendants there. They shouted at the patients from their chairs in the nurse's station and loudly talked and laughed about them like children or animals. Giving medications in such big and complex regimens was a chore. They didn't love. And although I detested this and really couldn't wait to be off that ward, it rubbed off on me! Writing so many orders--what a chore! Working on this ward--what a burden! So, as I was looking at that medication list, I was not loving the person, even though I was pitying them.

And as soon as I forgot about love, I forgot about the meaning of life, the dignity of persons, the mystery of each soul's holy journey, and the importance of suffering in salvation. Who knows whether that person on three pages of medication was becoming a great saint or mystic? Beneath the shroud of dementia and crippled limbs, under the veil of an incontinent, flailing old woman, perhaps God was adorning an exquisite saint. Perhaps in heaven her beauty and nobility will be breathtaking. And moreover, what if her suffering was saving my soul? Yours? Our country, our world? How could I dare to know? (Job 38 comes to mind.) Certainly, simplifying her regimen with palliation in mind isn't a bad idea, but I only safely stay in that mindset when I remember love.

So forget not love. It's a deadly mistake.

Sunday, September 8, 2013

My Plans for the Future

For a long time, I've thought about where the best use of my God-given skills and education lies. How can I provide the best care to women, the best example to my peers, and the best remedy to our culture?

I want to be a doctor to the whole person and that includes maintaining education in primary care areas as well as in OB and gynecology. I also think having an in-house NFP teacher, in-house dietician, and in-house psychologist (IPS, anyone?) would be excellent. A multispecialty group practice appeals to me, so that whatever practice I have can be a patient-centered medical home.

Of course, part of the future is offering women's healthcare in accord with Catholic teaching, which is to say to offer the best women's healthcare. Perhaps I would imitate Mystical Rose or Caritas Complete Women's Care or the Vitae Clinic with my own private practice. Maybe I would imitate Tepeyac Family Center/Divine Mercy Care and become an ACO.

St. Guiseppe Moscati, doctor to the poor
(well, the very romanticized movie version)
Also, I see many groups of women who are frequently forgotten: the uninsured, the illegal immigrants and refugees, religious, the abused, former prostitutes and drug addicts, the incarcerated, and the difficult. I want to find and care for these women, even though I might have trouble keeping the lights on!

Becoming a subspecialist in a maternal-fetal-medicine (MFM) also appeals to me. As an MFM, I could operates on the unborn, work with infertile couples, and take care of very high-risk pregnancies, also appeals to me. I have this dream of showing people how human the unborn are, how like us and how worthy of attention they are. What if we could re-implant babies who implanted in the wrong place? What if we could treat things like Potter's syndrome? (What if we could pull out all the "medical reasons" for abortion?) There are other advantages to this idea, too: my refusal to prescribe contraceptives and refer for abortions might irk fewer colleages if I was in MFM and had fewer occasions to do these things.

♪  MFM  ♪
But as much as I like the MFM dream, a subspecialty (long fellowships, expensive services) take me a little away from the poor. So I always thought I would have to choose: to serve the poor in those impoverished or those unborn. But what if these didn't conflict?

If I started a women's healthcare center and used midlevel professionals (NPs and PAs) and allied health (nurses, MAs, psychologists, social work, and dieticians) to establish a large group of primary care and OB/GYN providers for women, we could serve the poor and offer cutting-edge infertility and prenatal service with excellent gynecology. That's the future I'm working for now. (Now, if you'll excuse me, I need to go study for a shelf exam so that people don't laugh in my face when I say I want to do a surgical subspecialty.)